Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Watching a Train Wreck in Slow Motion

 A Train Wreck in SloMo

David Frum, a former Republican and conservative intellectual, has extensively documented and criticized what he describes as the
decline and "Trumpification" of the Republican Party over the past two decades. He argues that the GOP has moved away from traditional conservative principles and democratic norms, leading to an "institutional collapse". In November 2024, following Donald Trump's victory, Frum formally announced he was leaving the party.  

Key Arguments on the GOP's Decline:
 
Frum has analyzed the Republican Party's trajectory in numerous articles for The Atlantic and in his books, including Trumpocracy and Trumpocalypse. His key arguments include: 
  • Move to the extreme: Frum argues that the party has been "radicalized" and moved away from the political center, driven by fringe voices and the "conservative entertainment complex" found on talk radio and Fox News.
  • Rejection of governance: He contends that Republicans have stopped "taking governance seriously" and that their strategy often involves obstructionism rather than pragmatic problem-solving, which has eroded public trust.
  • Rise of Trump and "alternative reality": Frum views Donald Trump not as the cause, but as a symptom of the GOP's failures. He describes the party and its ecosystem as operating within an "alternative reality" based on lies and "paranoid delusions".
  • Loss of traditional values: Frum, who self-identifies as a conservative who believes in free markets, limited government, and American global leadership, has found himself increasingly at odds with a party that he believes shows contempt for democratic traditions, institutions, and even the military.
  • Demographic shifts: He has noted the "diploma divide" as a significant factor in the political realignment, with the party relying increasingly on non-college-educated, working-class voters who have different demands than the traditional GOP base.
  • Erosion of accountability: Frum criticizes the party's leadership and donors for enabling Trump's behavior and for failing to hold him accountable for his actions, such as efforts to overturn the 2020 election. 
Political Stance:
 
Frum's criticisms led to his forced resignation from the conservative think tank, the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), in 2010 after he criticized the GOP's blanket opposition to the Affordable Care Act. 
 
He became a prominent figure in the "Never Trump" movement and announced in November 2024 that he could no longer be a member of a party that would elect Donald Trump as president after his documented attempts to undermine democracy. Frum's work consistently calls for a return to principled conservatism and the necessity of engaging with a broad spectrum of voters to form a governing majority. 
 
The object of Frum's criticism, in the meantime, has gone from the barely sublime to the truly ridiculous.
  



 US mid-terms are on Tuesday, November 3rd.  Predictions are that the Republicans will suffer major losses.  We will check back after the results are out.
 
 

BC Politics - A Transition

Changing of the Guard in BC

 Well, what was unthinkable a bit over a month ago has happened.  Approximately 49% of BC voters  gave the Conservative Party of BC a solid majority of 67 seats.  The combined opposition (NDP and Greens) garnered around 48%.  

Mere weeks ago, the Conservatives seemed on the verge of self-destruction.  Caucus members were leaving in droves.  The leader, one Kerry-Lynne Findlay (known as KLF), was being pilloried for a number of comments and management issues.  Then, she was gone.  An unknown MLA from the Cariboo, Lorne Doerkson, was appointed interim party leader.

 


I do have to say at least one good thing about Mr Doerkson.  He knows how to smile.  One of the previous leaders just seemed to be in a perpetually sour mood.   That was John Rustad until HE was forced out.  Mr Doerkson became the 4th leader of the Conservative Party since 2023, just days before the NDP called a snap election.  That decision was immediately questioned, and, as it turned out, was a significant strategic blunder.

There are questions now about who some of the Conservative members are who now sit in government, supposedly for the next 4 or 5 years.  Here is Google AI's summary:

Concerns regarding B.C. Conservative MLAs and candidates have centered on internal party turmoil, controversial statements, and policy stances: [1, 2, 3]
  • Far-Right Policies and Rhetoric: The party faced criticism under former leader Kerry-Lynne Findlay for policies opposing Indigenous rights—specifically plans to repeal the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA)—alongside anti-trans rhetoric and the hiring of political staff with ties to separatist movements. Interim leader Lorne Doerkson also faced pressure regarding plans to repeal DRIPA. [1, 2, 3]
  • Extreme Views and Candidate Controversies: The party faced scrutiny over vetting and candidate comments, including anti-gay and anti-2SLGBTQ+ remarks from members like Heather Maahs, and anti-Indigenous initiatives promoted by candidates like Harman Bhangu. Other candidates faced removal or criticism for violent, anti-Semitic, Islamophobic, or conspiratorial remarks. [1, 2]
  • Internal Leadership Struggles and Caucuses Exoduses: Deep ideological divisions between the party's more centrist and far-right wings led to significant internal friction, caucus departures, and leadership turnover (including Findlay's resignation and the exit of multiple MLAs). [1, 2]
  • Investigations: Internal conflict also involved allegations of unauthorized private investigations into leaks using party funds, as well as investigations surrounding job-for-resignation quid pro quo offers


 So we will see.  No need for another election for at least 4 years.  What do voters need to watch for?  Here are some of the promises the Conservatives have made:

Taxes and Economy
  • Tax Cuts: Raise the basic personal income tax exemption to $32,000, cutting provincial income taxes by roughly $1,000 per year for working individuals (and saving families an estimated $2,000 annually). [1, 2]
  • No New Taxes: Pledge not to raise taxes on British Columbians. [1]
  • Business & Alcohol: Remove the Provincial Sales Tax (PST) on Canadian alcohol for the duration of the U.S. trade war, provide a temporary PST elimination on business machinery, software, and equipment, and stop proposed PST expansions. [1, 2, 3]
  • Deficit and Review: Launch an immediate independent review of provincial finances on day one to rein in the province's deficit, freeze outside hiring, and cut consultant spending. [1, 2]
  • Energy & Resources: Double BC's Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) production by 2032 and triple it by 2035. [1]
Healthcare and Social Policy
  • Hospitals & Infrastructure: Complete the Surrey Hospital and BC Cancer Centre in Cloverdale on budget, and build a new women's and children's hospital in Surrey. [1, 2]
  • Emergency Rooms: Maintain healthcare funding while launching an expert commission within the first 100 days involving frontline doctors and nurses to keep emergency rooms and maternity wards open. [1, 2]
  • Toxic Drugs & Mental Health: End the safe supply of drugs, expand detox and treatment services, and amend the Mental Health Act to allow mandatory care for individuals with severe addictions or mental health challenges who cannot care for themselves. [1]
  • Education & SOGI: Repeal SOGI 123 (a sexual orientation and gender identity teaching resource) while ensuring safe school environments, restore letter grades for grades 4 through 9, and bring back parental notification and opt-out rights. [1, 2]
  • Indigenous Policy: Repeal the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA). [1, 2]
Public Safety and Justice
  • Police & Streets: Hire and deploy 250 more police via an expanded Justice Institute of B.C. Police Academy, alongside 500 RCMP officers and 150 civilian staff over five years in rural and regional communities. Take stricter enforcement against hard drugs and public disorder.
  • Auto Insurance: Abolish the ICBC no-fault insurance model to restore consumer choice and justice for serious injuries while keeping premiums low. [1, 2, 3]
Infrastructure and Transportation
  • George Massey Tunnel: Scrap the planned Massey Tunnel replacement between Delta and Richmond and replace it with a bridge.
  • Surrey Transit: Work with the federal government to fund and build rapid transit along Surrey's King George corridor with a SkyTrain extension to Newton.
  • Wildfires: Implement a Wildfire Action Plan to purchase water bomber aircraft ahead of future fire seasons.
  • Respect Local Democracy Act: Introduce early legislation to permanently separate provincial and municipal election schedules so provincial elections cannot coincide with local races

 So, there you have it.  Promises made and a majority in the Legislature with which to carry it out.  We will revisit this list occasionally to see how they are fulfilled.

 

[UPDATE - October 28th, 2026]  Some baseline numbers to be used for future comparison.

  • Unemployment - at the end of September /26 - 6.4%
  • Employment change - fell by 20,200 in September (0.7%)
  • Total Government debt - projected to be $180.9 Billion by the end of the 2026/27 fiscal year
  • Debt to GDP is approximately 39%
  • Debt servicing costs - $6.3 Billion annually
  • Deaths from unregulated drugs - about 126 per month Jan to Aug/26 
  • Wait time by hospital varies, so I'm using Kootenay Boundary Regional which is 2.25 hours
  • Percentage of BC residents without a family doctor or primary care provider - about 20-23% (approximately 1.26 million)   
 

WEF WTF ??

More on the WEF 

From an original comment on FB by Raymond Lavallee

When Stephen Harper arrived in office in 2006 with a sharp economic identity: austerity, fiscal discipline, resource-driven growth, global investment, and unwavering support for market-centric governance. The WEF was a perfect match. It wasn’t a social club or a symbolic stop on the diplomatic circuit — it was a strategic megaphone. From Davos, Harper could speak over the heads of domestic politics and communicate Canada’s economic philosophy directly to global capital. He didn’t just appear at the WEF; he championed it. He repeatedly described Davos as “an indispensable part of the global conversation” on stability and growth, and he meant it.
 
  
The peak of Harper’s relationship with the WEF came during the 2008–09 global financial crisis. While markets convulsed, governments panicked, and economic forecasts fell apart, Harper knew that investor confidence shapes reality as much as legislation does. So he did what many leaders avoided: he went to Davos in the middle of the chaos. From the WEF stage, he told the world Canada was stable — its banks were solid, its lending rules strict, its fiscal framework predictable. It was a masterclass in market reassurance. Harper used Davos to brand Canada as the safest port in a storm, and foreign investment followed. It wasn’t luck; it was strategy. Davos didn’t shape Harper — Harper used Davos to shape the world’s perception of Canada.
What made Harper and the WEF such perfect ideological partners was that neither had to pretend. The WEF’s mantra — deregulation, free trade, resource export expansion, private capital as the primary engine of progress — wasn’t something Harper tolerated; it was his worldview already. Harper didn’t go to Davos to network with strangers who might influence him. He went because he was already one of them. Davos celebrated him during the crisis era not as an up-and-comer but as the model of fiscally conservative governance. He became, for a time, the poster child of technocratic capitalism.
 
Harper also used Davos as a sales floor for his energy agenda. He pitched the oil sands, pipelines, and fossil-megaprojects as reliable long-term investments protected from geopolitical disruptions. He framed Canada’s resource sector as a bastion of global energy security — and in Davos, that message landed exactly the way he wanted it to. In a room full of sovereign funds, oil companies, and major lenders, Harper wasn’t just a politician. He was a salesman with a stable product.
 
All of this matters because the modern right has reinvented the WEF not as a conference, but as a monster. If attendance at Davos truly signalled subservience to a shadowy cabal, then Harper — not Mark Carney — would be the greatest villain of the conspiracy universe. But that’s not how these narratives work. The WEF only became “dangerous” once fear became politically profitable. When the WEF was useful to conservatives, it was praised. When it became useful to demonize rivals, it was turned into the boogeyman.
 
Harper didn’t fear Davos. He admired it because he understood its value. He didn’t see it as a threat to sovereignty — he saw it as a stage where a smart leader could control a global narrative. Today’s anti-WEF rhetoric isn’t about sovereignty or patriotism. It’s about weaponizing ignorance. And the proof is simple: when the right needed Davos, they applauded it. When they needed rage, they attacked it. The WEF never changed — only the politics did.