Friday, March 25, 2016

Fixing the World - Bang for the Buck Edition


One of my favourite podcasts is Freakonomics Radio.  Their episodes usually have, as you might guess from the name, an economics bent, they're entertaining, informative and, importantly, based on real-world data.

In a show from December 14, 2015, titled: "Fixing the World - Bang for the Buck Edition", the show's writer and host interviewed Bjorn Lomborg, who runs the Copenhagen Consensus Center.
"The Copenhagen Consensus Center is a think tank that researches and publishes the smartest solutions for the world's biggest problems. Its studies are conducted by more than 100 economists from internationally renowned institutions, including seven Nobel Laureates, to advise policy-makers and philanthropists how to spend their money most effectively."
 Fixing the world would seem to be a mammoth undertaking, and it is, but real progress can be achieved if good choices are made - by getting the best "bang for the buck".

During this program, there was a brief discussion about extending educational opportunities to more people, particularly poor people.  Education, obviously, is of prime importance in lifting people out of poverty.

In the USA's current election campaign, one issue has been the cost of post-secondary education.  One of the candidates for the Democrats, Bernie Sanders, has suggested that university education should be free.  You have to admit that it's an attractive option.

The Copenhagen Consensus Center has a different perspective.  It's contention is that the people attending university are mostly wealthy (in a relative sense), so free education at that level would really just be (another) subsidy for the well-off.  Far better, the Center believes, would be to offer many more scholarships, something that would direct funds to people who really need it.


LOMBORG: Yeah, the problem is that the way it’s formulated, they want to promise, and this is typical for these sorts of documents, they want to promise everybody to be able to get into, for instance, university. It’s a beautiful idea, but the problem is for most countries it ends up being a way to subsidize rich people’s kids to go to college. If you make college free, because most of the attendees at universities are from the high classes, that is effectively a subsidy to rich people’s kids. Instead what you should be doing is if you want to get more poor kids into college, you should be giving them scholarships. That’s a much cheaper much more directed way to make sure that you get a better socio-economic profile in college. But let’s not kid ourselves. This is not what makes productivity dramatically rise in the first 30 or 50 years of development. That’s much more about getting everyone educated so they can read and write.
The discussion then moved on to climate change, specifically fossil fuel subsidies and increasing the share of renewables by 2030.


 DUBNER: Let me ask you about a phenomenal and a poor ranking the Copenhagen Consensus Center has given for two goals in the climate change arena. Phenomenal mark goes to the proposal to “by 2030 phase out inefficient fossil-fuel subsidies.” But a poor mark to the proposal to “double the share of renewable energy in the global energy mix by 2030.” At first blush those might seem to be contradictory. Explain why one gets phenomenal the other poor.
The answer might surprise you, so I'll leave it there and let you investigate the response for yourself.  The full transcript of the interview can be found here.

Saturday, March 05, 2016

Climate Change Deniers Are Going Berserk - Again

Yes, it's true.  What with the Paris climate change meeting last fall, the new Canadian PM meeting with the premiers to discuss climate change, a federal Minister of Environment and Climate Change (and a woman, no less), the NDP in power in Alberta (and a woman, no less), Saskatchewan's Brad Wall in full pre-election mode.... the climate change denial trolls are out in force.

The "debating points" haven't changed.  All of them have been noted and addressed on the pages of Skeptical Science.

A few favourite "points" have reappeared, like this one: The earth was much warmer in the past and the climate has always been changing.

Very true, as the following chart shows (note the varying horizontal scale of years).



While it's very true to say that the earth has been warmer in the past, it's also irrelevant.

Here's the problem.  Until the last little bit at the right-hand side of the chart, we humans weren't here.  Neither were our crops, our coastal cities and 7 billion of us.  The concern is the very rapid increase on the far right.  It's unprecedented in the earth's history and certainly during all of human history.  Now, all of a sudden (geologically speaking) addition of CO2 is forcing a rapid change.  Are we ready for this?  I don't think so.



Some deniers, apparently those without access to Google, wonder how we even know what the earth's temperature was "back then".  Now, we could be talking about what temperatures were 6000 years ago (Stockwell Day's age of the earth) or a few billion years ago, which is the real age of the earth, according to science.  But I digress.  How do "they" know?  This is how.

Everyone in Alberta and Saskatchewan is all wound up over possible new pipelines.  With Keystone XL mired in American politics and Northern Gateway unlikely to ever happen, focus has shifted to Energy East.  A couple of points:

Oil shipped to any coast, such as New Brunswick, is destined for export, not for Canadian use.  The numbers explain why.  Refinery capacity in St John is about 300K bbl/day.  A pipeline would deliver about 1M bbl/day.  Can you imagine what that excess would do once it got to the coast?  You have 3 guesses.

Little discussion has revolved around whether or not we should even be encouraging more fossil fuel use by building another pipeline.  Rather than spend $35B on a pipeline, imagine what we might have if we spent $35B on alternative energy sources.

The pipeline, however, makes little economic sense, as this article points out.

And the price on carbon....  Conservatives are literally frothing at the mouth over yet another tax grab that, in their words, won't achieve anything.


Update - April 25, 2016, an article by Bill Nye - "Climate Deniers: It's Time to Stop Denying"



Presidential Election 2016 - It's Time for Canada to Lend a Hand

It's getting almost painful to watch what's happening south of the 49th.

Here's how we can help.



To see the full screen view, click here.


Sunday, February 28, 2016

Another Pipeline War

There is no shortage of pieces that analyze the effect of the West's near-constant interventionist policies in the Middle East.  Many of those policies can be clearly seen as root causes of the current problems with ISIS, among other jihadist groups.

This recent, lengthy article discusses how, once again, it's about oil, and pipelines.


Fixing Harper - Part 10 - Restoring Hope on the Prairies

In a recent article, posted on February 24th, 2016, the blog section of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) focused on the Canadian prairies, a region that has been especially damaged by many policies of the former Conservative government.




The post was called "How the Federal Liberals can Restore Hope on the Prairies".

The swath of destruction wreaked by the Conservatives was widespread and is briefly documented in the article.

One thing that the article does not mention is the losses incurred by prairie farmers since the Harper Conservatives dismantled the Canadian Wheat Board.  One comment posted after the article noted that prairie farmers have lost $6.5 Billion since the Wheat Board was done away with.  The damage is documented on the Canadian Wheat Board Alliance's website.

I wonder how many supporters of the Harper Conservatives who make their homes on the Prairies actually realize what was done to them?

The question is: can it be fixed?


Friday, February 12, 2016

Rex Pontificates - Trolls Proliferate

Rex Murphy, the CBC's purveyor of profound polemics, unleashed an attack on anyone concerned about climate change.

Trolls popped out of their holes in near-record numbers.

It was so much like a Republican convention.  And the "discussion" was just about as intelligent.


Reading through the comments to the article on Facebook (why, oh why do I bother?), the usual cogent points appeared, again and again.  Not a scintilla of sense, or facts.  "The climate is always changing", "it's -40C in Calgary today - what warming?", "it's not warming", "Arctic ice is expanding", "we produce so little CO2 in the grand scheme of things... How could it possibly affect the climate?", "30,000 scientists say it isn't happening".

What can one say in the face of such profound nonsense?  Maybe only this: Actually spend some time reading Skeptical Science.  If you have an open mind, you may find something useful.  Also consider that NASA might know more about the atmosphere than Rex Murphy.

This got me wondering, though.  Rex has done this before.

He got all serious about the niqab "debate" during the all-too-recent longest election campaign in Canadian history.  Remember that one?

He tried to calm fears about the evil Stephen Harper, in an article appearing in the National Post back in 2012.

He appeared on Strombo, trying to reassure us that Harper was "just an ordinary guy".

It goes on.  And on.  Rex retired from "Cross Country Checkup" last September.  He should retire from commentary as well.  Some things have a best before date and Rex has passed it already.




Tuesday, February 09, 2016

Behind Closed Doors - Taxing Taxpayers' Credibility


Behind Closed Doors.  How the Rich Won Control of Canada's Tax System... and Ended Up Richer.

by Linda McQuaig




This rather entertaining read was published almost 30 years ago.  Oddly, the situation hasn't changed very much, other than to continue the trend of allowing the rich to enhance their financial situation to the detriment of everyone else in the country and the hollowing out of the nation's fiscal resources and, consequently, it's ability to do what needs to be done to run the country.

Way back in 1988, this brief review appeared.

Not all were positive.  McQuaig obviously takes a quite ideological stand (according to some) on the need for fairness and equity in the tax system.  It could be argued that allowing the continued existence of a tax system that allows huge amounts to income to remain completely un-taxed is an ideological position, but there you are.  

A much more recent interview with Linda McQuaig makes it clear what her concerns are with the tax system.

And this analysis, from 2005, examines the data from a slightly more recent perspective.

Don't call it class warfare to demand better treatment of employment income and cuts to the generous perks handed out to the rich.  The class warfare has been going on for decades and the top 1 or 2% have been the main beneficiaries.


It may have been published nearly 30 years ago but it's well worth a read.