Monday, February 08, 2016

To Pipeline or Not to Pipeline

Coincident with the plunge in the price of crude oil (and commodities in general), has been an increasingly virulent debate over pipelines.

Supporters claim that pipelines are safer than rail for transporting crude oil.  Perhaps so, but is that the full extent of the argument?

Even if pipelines are better than rail, they aren't perfect, and more and more people are demanding something much closer to perfect when toxic substances are being shipped past their doors, under their soil or across their waterways.

Pipeline proponents wave the national unity flag and claim that Energy East would be able to supply all of Eastern Canada's energy needs so we wouldn't need to keep supporting that nasty Saudi regime, even though we seem quite happy selling them weapons.  The problem is.... Energy East would be for export, not domestic consumption.  And that's assuming, at the present price of crude, that it would make ANY economic sense to sell a product well below it's cost of production.

The elephant in the room is still climate change.  But we're still having this old argument being put forward that there isn't a scientific consensus.  It's the same old song and dance, even though the Science IS in.  So why are some people content to keep doing everything the way we've always done things?  Since climate change IS the world most pressing problem, why is anyone still listening to this same old nonsense?


What about a carbon tax?  What about alternative sources of energy?  What about increased efficiencies? What about a different discussion?

Speaking of BC's Carbon Tax.  Those on the side of doing nothing about climate change assert that it hasn't worked.  Ignore for a moment the fact that the tax hasn't been increased for years and needs to be much higher, consider this: Studies show that it IS working. 

As the article points out: 
"Yet Cross argues (without evidence) that it is “a fantasy” to think we can reduce fossil fuel use (and greenhouse gases) without harming the economy. This is a bizarre claim. Canadians know from everyday experience in their homes and businesses that there are many economically sensible ways to conserve energy and reduce fuel use – like switching to fluorescent light bulbs, or fuel efficient cars and furnaces.
If putting a price on carbon is such an economically bad idea, why is it being recommended by the Canadian Council of Chief Executives, the World Bank, and the CEOs of major oil companies?”
Other opponents point out that solar power (or wind, or geothermal, or whatever) has it's own carbon footprint.  Very true.  Nothing we can do, as humans on this planet, will be perfect.  Everything will have an impact at some level.  But let's consider that some forms of energy production are considerably better than others.  The Parliamentary Office of Science & Technology in the UK recently came out with this article, the "Carbon Footprint of Electricity Generation".   Of course some will look askance at such reports.  This is Canada, after all, and acknowledging science disappeared under the Harper regime.  So obviously, appeals to science-based decision-making wouldn't work here.

Or in the USA, where the Congressional Committee on Science is headed by a gentleman who uses snowballs in Congress to "prove" that climate change and global warming isn't happening.  

Despite the obvious fact that a decade of Harper failed to get any pipelines built, some Albertans rant constantly about how Trudeau isn't helping to get Alberta crude to market.  Now that Harper has been defeated, Michael Harris has turned his acerbic wit on the oilpatch supporters, taking a quote from the former, short-lived, Alberta premier, Jim Prentice.

There is talk of a revolution.  An overthrow of government....  A kudatah, no less.


And here we are.


Saturday, February 06, 2016

Fixing Harper - Part 9 - The Conservatives as Soap Opera

It's like the CONservatives think nobody remembers last season - the last 10 seasons, for that matter.  But here it is.  The National Soap Opera on Parliament Hill.
Rick Mercer Calls On Tories To Cut The Harper-Era Amnesia Shtick
Rona Ambrose said that this session of Parliament would be better.  Less heckling and behaving like children.  That's not what's happening.

Tony wants the Liberals to"be more transparent".  $50M on gazebos, Tony?  Remember that?

The CONs in general are upset that pot isn't legal yet.  Remember how they claimed legalizing pot would usher in the end of the world?

And Jason can't stop acting like a racist, bigoted, jackass.  Not much has changed, obviously.  Certainly not for Jason....

So, here we are.

 


You'd think the CONservatives would take October 19, 2015 as a learning experience.  You'd be wrong about that.


Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Those Advancing Years

By the time I awoke this morning, it had already arrived.

According to family legend, my quite pregnant mother was staying at her parents' place awaiting "the time".  There was a winter storm of sorts, her doctor happened to visit her at home (are you old enough to remember home visits?) and told her that it was time to get to the hospital.  So she was driven, in the doctor's jeep, to the hospital, the better part of an hour away.  I was born, around 6 am, in the hospital that later became a nurses' residence.

That happened 65 years ago.

So I've been contemplating all of this.  The arrival at the time of life where you are actually referred to as a "senior citizen" and not just an old fart.

I remember commenting a few years ago about some complaints by some much younger folk, so I dug it out to read again.  I don't think much has changed.  Certainly none of the things I mentioned in the original post have gone away.... and I was so hoping....

I know, it's just a number I've passed and it's just another name that I can be called and it's probably better than being called "jackass" or late for dinner, but there it is.

I now get discounts at the local store on certain days.  The provincial vehicle insurance system gives me a 25% discount.  There are breaks on property tax.  I start to receive government "pogey" in the form of CPP.  I can ski at some places for a reduced rate.  All very nice.  After all, I might need the money saved for prescription drugs....

I still have most of my hair, and I'm not just counting the fuzz on my face.  I have most of my own teeth (no false ones yet).  Most of the collection of body parts still work pretty well, at least most of the time.  I managed to stay well ahead of a much younger fellow on the return loop of the local ski trail earlier today.  Once I'm in condition, I can still climb the ski uptracks out in the backcountry at least as fast as everyone else.

So I guess I don't need to complain.  So I won't.


Monday, January 25, 2016

Fixing Harper - Part 8 - Conservatives Still Whining

Yes, the new government has been in power for a mere 3 months and a few days and to listen to the Conservatives, you'd think the sky was falling.  Of course, as they predicted.

Conservative supporters and former government ministers have been heard bleating about how "...friends of the Trudeau PMO go to the front of the line everywhere."  As Michael Harris responded: "Oh no...not patronage, not in the Federal Government!  How did all those Cons end up in the Senate?  The Stork?"

The "Rona and Tony show" are being ridiculed on other fronts as well.  Michael Harris is at his best, again, as he pillories the two former Harper acolytes over their reversals on the long-form census, science, pot, arms deals with the Saudis..... and on it goes.

Other editorials are starting to point out that actually, the Liberals are pretty much doing what they promised to do.  An op-ed in The Star put it this way: 
But Trudeau’s early days have not been the fiasco the Tories make out. There’s fresh energy and purpose in Ottawa. For the first time, the cabinet is gender-balanced. Relations with premiers, First Nations and cities are much better. The Liberals are bringing in more tax fairness, and more support for a greener economy. MPs and scientists are free to speak their minds again. Draconian security laws are being reviewed.
There's just no pleasing some people. 

Even on the issue of falling oil prices, articles are starting to appear that suggest, pretty clearly, that this might be an opportunity, even in the midst of a economic disaster for Alberta and the country.  Alberta's Clean Energy Shift is a Massive Economic Opportunity, comments an article in the Huffington Post.

There are obvious reasons why oil at $30/bbl (or lower) create some problems, and not just the budgetary and employment ones that everyone might think of.  This article takes a look at 10 problems that low oil prices create and the mismatch between oil supply and demand.




Meanwhile, employment related to solar power are exploding even while jobs related to the oil & gas industry are disappearing, as discussed in Fortune Magazine on-line.

Pointed barbs and nasty comments are flying back and forth over the possibility (or not) of the Energy East pipeline.  Quebec mayors say no.  Alberta's Wild Rose Party blames it all on the Alberta NDP government.  The ex-HarperCons do more arm-waving.  Alberta and Ontario's premiers seem to be on the same page.  People keep talking about the safety record of oil pipelines.

And Parliament gets back into session this week.

As Canadians, though, there is at least one thing that we can be thankful for, as summed up in this charming image: 

New friends. Former Republican vice-presidential candidate Sarah Palin endorsed Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump at the Iowa State University on Tuesday. (Mary Altaffer/Associated Press)


Friday, January 22, 2016

Fixing Harper - Part 7 - The Checklist

It's just so refreshing to be able to talk about how some of the damage of the past 10 years is being reversed, where possible.



So, in the interests of keeping track, here is a list of some of the Harperisms that the new Liberal government might/could tackle.  Some have already been announced.

Undoing the Tories: A Complete Guide to All the Harperisms That the Liberals Might or Have Killed.

There is also this article from Abacus Data: "Promises, Promises: Which Liberal campaign promises do Canadians want the government to follow through on?"

Some readers might recall Allan Gregg.  He was a former Tory strategist and he recently offered some not-very-flattering opinions about what the Harper regime did during it's tenure.  You can read about his comments here.  In particular, he slammed the regime's attack on evidence-based research.

It will be a big job.

Fixing Harper - Part 6 - Tax Fairness

In fairness, this problem of tax fairness didn't start with the former Harper regime.  It's been developing for some time.  Both Conservative and Liberal governments are responsible.

The new government has been making nice-sounding noises on many things and the mandate letter given to the new National Revenue Minister seems to be singing the same tune, but what are the chances that real changes will take place?




This article from iPolitics discusses the elusive nature of the problem.

The organization Canadians for Tax Fairness published a research report called: "What is Wrong at the CRA and How to Fix It".  It should be mandatory reading for all taxpayers.

So if the new Liberal really wants to start making a difference, here is yet another issue that should be high up on the list.

Ill-advised tax breaks for the wealthy and corporations.  Failure to crack down on off-shore tax havens.  Even Oxfam weighed in recently about the concentration of wealth in the hands of so few people.  The root reason seems clearly to be tax policies of federal governments.

One recent Canadian case involves Cameco, the uranium mining giant.  More on that story here...

Reigning in the CRA in it's partisan attacks on charities the former government didn't happen to approve of is another important step.  It appears that this is happening.  Already.

As a random commentator put it:  Friedman, Reagan and Thatcher are all dead.  It's time to bury them.

To which I'd add.... and Harper is gone too.

Thursday, January 21, 2016

That Pesky TPP Thing

Yes, the Trans Pacific Partnership.  That "Trade Deal" that isn't really a trade deal.

We're going to hear a whole lot more about it in the coming months.  In the meantime, here's some reading material about it.

From Huff Post Politics: The TPP Hands Control Over Trade to the World's Wealthiest.

From BoingBoing: Independent Economists: TPP Will Kill 450,000 US Jobs.... 

From the Vancouver Sun: Nobel Laureate Warns of TPP Dangers

From the Washington Post: People Are Freaking Out About the TPP ISDS....

Very few governments have turned down any trade deals, but this isn't, apparently, about trade.  It's about "Investor State Dispute Settlement" which will usurp the rights of sovereign countries to make and enforce their own laws and regulations in a manner that is best for their country.

The Green Party of Canada has posted an article on the subject, giving several good reasons why the deal must not be ratified.

A recent article from The Tyee delves into some of the history of other trade agreements and links the fallout from those to what will happen as a result of the TPP.

One commentator put it this way:


Top ten reasons PARLIAMENT must kill the TPP 
1. The Trans Pacific Partnership is not a partnership. It was initiated in the US by large corporations to consolidate their control over the smaller economies of the member states.
2. It is not about “free trade.”It has more to do with investor rights which serve to debilitate national governments (nation states) as is already happening with NAFTA and other such agreements.
3. As they can already do under NAFTA corporations will be able to sue governments for non-compliance. This has already cost Canadian taxpayers millions of dollars.
4. It is about labor mobility. Corporations want to be able to hire the
cheapest possible labor, where ever and whenever. There will be open
immigration to bring in low wage workers from other countries. In 2013 the RBC
did this very thing.
5. It is an extension and intensification of existing agreements that are already debilitating the middle class in the US, Canada and numerous other countries. They hollow out democracy and destroy our social fabric.
6. It is about ISDS. These are to be legal tribunals where laws and judgements can be made to supersede a country’s regulatory structures. This in itself will make it next to impossible to make real progress on climate change and other environmental issues.
7. Over the past forty years there has been a massive retreat from real governance in this country. Politicians have yielded too much power to corporations. The neo-liberal free market economy, dominated by corporate greed, is a race to the bottom where all countries end up as Third World countries.
8. Over the past forty years Canada has suffered one incremental loss of sovereignty after another. We are generally regarded internationally as a weak-kneed American vassal state. Signing on to the TPP for us is the final
capitulation.
9. Governments everywhere must get back in the business of real leadership and quit pandering to what is a global corporate fascism being consolidated by agreements like the TPP.
10. We cannot assume for a minute we are immune to consequences. Like Greece we too can hit bottom.

It needs to be stopped.

Update - An older article from January 2015, written by Robert Reich, was titled "Why the TPP Agreement is a Pending Disaster"